The Post-World War I Housing Crisis and Interracial Tensions
Part of

Author
Timothy Tay Soon Inn
19161930

A housing crisis, combined with White resistance to Black settlement, created high rents and overcrowding for migrants in the first wave of the Great Migration.

West Philadelphia experienced a housing crisis during WWI due to the combination of the arrival of vast numbers of African Americans and the slow rate of wartime housing construction. The insufficient supply of available houses meant new residents often had to live in crowded blocks and residences. Racism compounded the problem. Often White residents threatened Black migrants attempting to move into their neighborhood.

The Great Migration created a severe housing crisis in Philadelphia during the first World War as the city struggled to accommodate the huge influx of newcomers. New housing construction slowed dramatically from 1916 to 1918 due to the wartime labor and supply shortages, resulting in little available new housing. Migrants packed into every available space. Sadie Tanner Mossell, in her dissertation study of Black families, observed that housing conditions were deplorable, and the press reported severe congestion and overcrowding.[1] The renewal of Black migration in the early 1920s also saw the emergence of another housing crisis. Most migrants moved to neighborhoods in North, South, and West Philadelphia where Black communities were already established, which led to overcrowding. In West Philadelphia, for example, the press reported the plight of 16 people living in one room over a garage.[2]

The housing crisis was not merely the result of a shortage of houses, but also an effect of White resistance to Black resettlement in neighborhoods. Drawing on press reports, Mossell observed that White Philadelphians were determined to ensure that Black migrants lived only in areas that already had Black communities. Vacant houses in other areas were not for rent or for sale to Black migrants.[3] This discriminatory segregation was also seen in rent increases for Black migrants after 1917. Taking advantage of the influx of southern Blacks, many White realtors wanted to sell properties to Black migrants because they could make a tremendous profit. A White realtor, in an interview with the Philadelphia Tribune, commented that realtors would “charge four or five hundred dollars more because ‘niggers’ ought to be made to pay for the privilege of living in a decent, respectable neighborhood.”[4] The Philadelphia Housing Association (PHA) estimated that sections of West Philadelphia experienced the highest rent increases, with an average of 100 percent from 1914 to the early 1920s.[5]  

White discrimination was also seen in the increase in interracial conflicts in several parts of Philadelphia. In West Philadelphia, violence stemmed from White resistance to attempts by Black migrants to move into the area.

  • In 1916, a gang of “White thugs” fired gunshots and threw bricks and stones to drive a Black family from their recently purchased house at 4923 Stiles Street. The perpetrators went unpunished.[6] Similar confrontations between Whites and Black migrants continued after the war.
  • In September 1918, C. E. Wright, president of the West Philadelphia Business Men’s Association, gave an African American woman 30 days to move from her new house at 5451 Master Street. In this instance, the woman had a more favorable outcome—she explained her case to Police Superintendent Mills, and was given protection.[7]
  • In a separate case, a White policeman living at 5906 Haverford Avenue threatened a prospective Black buyer of an adjoining house at 5908 Haverford Avenue. He also issued threats against the African American who eventually purchased the house. In response, Black realtor Andrews F. Stevens, Jr., a former city councilman and partner in the Brown and Stevens Bank, intervened and arranged with Police Superintendent Mills for protection to be provided to the new owner.[8]

Racial tensions continued to flare in the 1920s. In 1928, White mob activity against a Black family at 5547 Media Street was serious enough for the police to form a riot squad to deal with potential disturbances.[9]

Decades
1910s, 1920s
[1] Sadie T. Mossell, "The Standard of Living Among One Hundred Negro Migrant Families in Philadelphia," Annals of the American Academy of Social and Political Science 98 (November 1921): 7; “Newly Arrived Negroes Lack Sufficient Shelter,” Evening Public Ledger, 22 March 1917; “Housing War Work Within Our Gates,” Evening Public Ledger, 19 March 1918.
[2] “Congestion in Philadelphia Menaces Health,” Pittsburgh Courier, 14 July 1923.
[3] Mossell, " Standard of Living,” 9.
[4] “Courts Refuse to Prosecute Man for Protecting His Home,” Philadelphia Tribune, 3 May, 1919.
[5] Philadelphia Housing Association, Housing in Philadelphia (Philadelphia: Philadelphia Housing Association, 1922); “House Rents Rise 103 P.C. in Decade,” Philadelphia Inquirer, 31 May 1925.
[6] “White Thugs Allowed to Demolish Home,” Philadelphia Tribune, 22 July 1916.
[7] “Mills Stops Mob Leaders,” Philadelphia Tribune, 14 September 1918.
[8] Ibid.
[9] “Boys Charged With Inciting Riot Freed,” Philadelphia Tribune, 10 May 1928; “Davis Creates ‘Riot Squad’ For Mobbists,” Philadelphia Tribune, 31 May 1928.

Continue reading The Great Migration

Southern African Americans migrated to West Philadelphia for increased economic opportunity and the potential of homeownership.

A segregated waiting room crowded with travelers at the Jacksonville railroad depot.

Southern African American migrants shared a complex relationship with Philadelphia’s middle-class Black families with multigenerational ties to the city.

A postcard advertising rowhouses for sale in 1914, just two years before Philadelphia experienced a severe housing crisis.

A housing crisis, combined with White resistance to Black settlement, created high rents and overcrowding for migrants in the first wave of the Great Migration.

Armstrong Association Fundraising Campaign Stamp

Concerned Philadelphians addressed the housing issues and discrimination faced by migrants.